ɯıɹnd ʎddɐɥ

23 February 2013

Purim Sameach!

5MFI Purim card

Purim fun ‘trivia’

Unlike other facts in Five Minutes for Israel these ‘facts’ are not meticulously researched but copy pasted from various sources. If they don’t stand the most rigourous examination? Hey, it’s Purim!

Tomb of Esther and Mordechai

Tomb of Esther and Mordechai,
Hamadan, Iran

  1. Purim is a Jewish holiday that commemorates the deliverance of the Jewish people in the ancient Persian Empire from destruction in the wake of a plot by Haman, a story recorded in the Biblical Book of Esther (Megillat Esther).
  2. Purim is a joyful spring holiday that features a festive meal, gift-giving, costumes, noisemakers in the synagogue, and required drunkenness. Purim is thus sometimes nicknamed the Jewish Mardi Gras or the Jewish Halloween.
  3. God’s name isn’t even mentioned once in the entire Scroll of Esther.
  4. The longest verse in the Bible is found in the Scroll of Esther VIII: The original text contains 43 words while the English translation has 90.
  5. The day on which Purim is celebrated (14th of Adar) can never occur on, Sabbath. The 15th of Adar does occasionally fall on the Sabbath. The Jews of Jerusalem, who celebrate the 15th of Adar then must celebrate a three day Purim.
  6. Purim is such a joyous holiday that the rabbis teach it will still be observed in the messianic age, when most other holidays will be abolished.
  7. Purim has been celebrated since at least the second century CE, and probably long before.
  8. Haman’s name is read out during the public chanting of the Megillah  54 times. The congregation engages in noise making to blot out his name. The practice can be traced back to the Tosafists (the leading French and German rabbis of the 13th century).
  9. On Purim, Iranian Jews visit the tombs of Esther and Mordechai in Hamadan, N.E. Iran.
  10. There is also a tradition that Esther was buried at Bar’am, in Northern Israel, only 3 kilometers from the Lebanese border.
  11. King Ahasuerus is traditionally identified with Xerxes I (519 BC-465 BC) during the time of the Achaemenid empire.
  12. In a speech of Hitler on January 30, 1944, he said that, if the Nazis went down in defeat, the Jews could celebrate “a second Purim”.
  13. On October 16, as they put the noose around Nazi leader Julius Streicher’s neck, Newsweek reported: “He stared at the witnesses facing the gallows and shouted Purimfest, 1946”.
  14. In 2011, some Iranians observed Purim as a day of mourning for the ancient Persians who—according to the Iranian version of the story being broadcast by the state news agency Fars—were massacred by the Jews under the command of the Jewish Queen Esther.
YouTube Preview Image

If you are puzzled by the post title try standing on your head.

Posted in 5MFI Blog, Trad Graphics | Tagged | Comments Off

More Pope

18 February 2013

Maradiaga and the Jews

Another papal candidate with a ?

By David Guy (@5MFI)

The Pope matters. Since I wrote Papabile a new candidate with a history has caught the tipsters’ eyes: Cardinal Oscar Andres Rodriguez Maradiaga of Honduras. Prof. Alan Dershovitz wrote in a letter to the editor of the Miami-Herald that Maradiaga was a notorious anti-Semite. (I wonder if the Cardinal could sue? That would be an interesting law suit). Intriguingly, Maradiaga together with Cardinals Cláudio Hummes was considered to be opposed to Ratzinger’s elevation to the papacy.
Continue reading

Posted in 5MFI Blog | Tagged , , , | Comments Off

Papabile†

13 February 2013

Does the new Pope matter?

Will he be good for the Jews?

By David Guy (@5MFI)

It seems a bit odd for a Jew or an Israeli to concern himself with the election of the new pope, doesn’t it? However, Christians, Catholics and their place in both the wider Middle East and North Africa and Israel/ Palestine will be a major issue for the new pontificate. The Catholic Church is an important landowner and employer in Israel/Palestine and purely domestic relations will pay a part. In addition, Africa and South America, the regions where Catholicism is growing fastest, also have growing and problematic Muslim populations.

However irrational it may seem, if he chooses that direction, the new Pope will not be the first world leader who felt throwing Israel under the bus would help elsewhere. Nor would he be the  first Christian leader, whether from fear, ignorance or power politics, to throw Christians under the bus (see Cognitiva dissonantiam pro Christianis) in this region.

As much as what the Pope does what he says is taken as very credible by millions of the faithful and even outside the faith. Quite a few take it as the word of God, even on issues where he doesn’t claim divine guidance. He matters. Continue reading

Posted in 5MFI Blog | Tagged , , , , | Comments Off

Growing pains

Palestine Authority

8 February 2013

Cultivating BDS BS

by David Guy (@5MFI)

Few of us and definitely the BDS mob know anything about farming and agricultural economics. With that thought in mind I have been dredging through the annual Palestine in Figures summaries provided by the Palestinian National Authority’s Central Bureau of Statistics to provide some ammunition  to counter tomorrow’s Farming Injustice attempts to intimidate supermarkets stocking Israeli produce. We should note that BDS has dropped the coming from the occupied territories nonsense. They have replaced it with coming from Israeli organisations profiting from the occupation nonsense. That is, in practise is everything coming from Israel.

Normally I would regard any Palestinian stats from official Palestinian sources with as much confidence as Stalin’s tractor production figures. Yet, they do have one undeniable advantage over other statistics. No one can accuse them of fabricating in Israel’s benefit! Unless stated otherwise any figures quoted are the Palestinian’s own. Continue reading

Posted in 5MFI Blog | Tagged , , | 1 Comment

Free books

7 February 2013

13 books from the GLORIA Center free online

A few years ago I almost worked for Professor Barry Rubin, of IDC Herzliya’s Global Research in International Affairs center AKA GLORIA Center. Not to be confused with Van Morrison and the Them‘s classic – no matter how drunk you are you can sing this – Gloria. It didn’t work out but no hard feelings. Barry Rubin is an always entertaining, always well informed and as we can see, very generous, expert on Israel, Palestine, The Middle East and American policy… So I have no reservations in recommending the Free book project. One can’t help but expand one’s knowledge and the PDF and HTML formats mean they can be downloaded to your computer. Beats reading the free newspaper they hand out on Israeli trains, by a mile.

Can’t wait until they come out on Kindle. (Hint, hint).

The GLORIA Center’s Free Books project features 13 books on our site, free and full-text to be read online or easily downloaded. The books are available in HTML and PDF and will soon be available for download in all other formats.

GLORIA invites you to take advantage of this free service, designed to promote education on Middle East, U.S. foreign policy, and other issues. We hope you find this material useful in your work, research, study, and analysis.

If you wish to make a tax-deductible contribution (in the United States, UK, or Israel) to help support this project and other GLORIA activities, please visit the donation page.

GLORIA Center

Click to link to GLORIA Center – Free book project

Posted in Action Items | Tagged , , , | Comments Off

When tillage begins

Bluff, Deceive, Swindle? Destroy?

Israel Fruit Delicious

Distribute wherever you see their Don’t but Israeli apartheid graphic.
Click for 180X269 pixels

5 January 2013

Farming Injustice, Saturday 9 February

BDS attacks Israeli Agricultural Export Companies

By David Guy @5MFI

When tillage begins, other arts follow. The farmers, therefore, are the founders of human civilization.~ Daniel Webster

Counter the BDS movement plan for a campaign against Israeli agriculture on Saturday 9th February.

  • Do not allow them an open playing field to intimidate supermarket chains and, not incidentally, their employees and customers.
  • Do not allow them to gain media coverage to delude viewers and supermarket execs that they are a mass movement without opposition.
  • Do not let them pretend that even on one day retailing Israeli produce causes the company a loss.

Continue reading

Posted in Action Items | Tagged , | Comments Off

Support these companies

Bluff, Deceive, Swindle? Destroy?

4 February 2012

An excellent BUYcott list

A new newish list of companies is circulating of companies the BDS movement claims support Israel. It was suggested that (H.T Maurice Solovitz) that this was an excellent buying guide. We agree! BTW if you like this you might like: One of a set

Support these companies Support these companies
Click for larger graphic

Makes you proud that Israel produces so much and so many major companies do business here.

Posted in 5MFI Blog | Tagged | Comments Off

Democracy tomorrow


Knesset and Menorah coin

21 January 2013

Show you care — give your vote away </SARC>

Israelis doing the right thing according to the BBC The Israelis who give their vote to Palestinians While most Israelis abuse their democratic right to vote by electing people the BBC doesn’t approve of: Netanyahu/Lieberman/Haredim, for example, some Israelis are giving that right away to the people who really want the best for Israel – random Palestinians.

To quote Pounce from the Biased BBC blog:

In a nutshell nice but dim Israelis will allow somebody they only know from Facebook to dictate their vote. The BBC thinks it is a wonderful idea in allowing Palestinians to vote in an election they have no right to vote in. I suppose something similar would be to allow Taliban freedom fighters living in Afghanistan to vote in the next British election.

A small disclaimer here. I hold joint Australian and Israeli citizenship but I do not exercise my right to vote in Oz. I feel that as I will not have to suffer the consequences of my decision I should not inflict my possibly mistaken and ill-informed choice on residents of that continent. And unlike random Palestinians I don’t harbor any grudges against Australia or Aussies so there is no danger of malice.

Will Yuval Ben-Ami be reporting regularly for the BBC from Israel? He seems ideally qualified, as a staff member of +972 Magazine, a leftist publication that believes Israel is destroying itself: that it is an apartheid state and that calls for foreign intervention to compel Israel to change. Information the BBC didn’t feel necessary to share with its readers.

Just consider this quote from the article.

Besides being a politics student at Ben Gurion University, she is a member of an organisation helping struggling Palestinian communities in the South Hebron hills benefit from renewable energy sources. In short, she is an informed, concerned Israeli citizen.

Actually Aya Shoshan is quite a bit more than a politics student and hardly a typical Israeli citizen. She may think of herself as a citizen of the world given that she has been active in social protest in several countries, that are not her own (wouldn’t you call that agitation)? She was a leader of the tent protest that was Israel’s equivalent and inspired by the Occupy movement – another factoid that Ben-Ami/BBC didn’t think important enough to share.

As for her being an informed, concerned Israeli citizen many would disagree. I think Pounce’s nice but dim is closer to accuracy. While I mostly agree with Pounce I’m not sure how nice or dim these Israelis really are. Perhaps we should hope for dim rather than Machiavellian.

This isn’t journalism. It is crude opinion – advertising for a political agenda, masquerading as journalism.

Action Item

Are you an Israeli? Tomorrow is election day. Exercise the right that so many have fought and died for. Go to your polling station and cast your vote.

Not sure (BTW neither am I) then vote for someone close to your beliefs. Take a look at Compass points if you are still perplexed.

Don’t give you vote away either at random† like the clowns the Ben-Ami/BBC seem to approve so much. Remember not voting is giving your vote away  to those who you wouldn’t want there.

Keep informed about the election

Parliamentary Democracy


† Actually there is little doubt the general direction of the Palestinians’ vote. Does any one really think that these generous Israelis would swallow their preferences and vote for Netanyahu/Lieberman if their new friend instructed them to?

Posted in 5MFI Blog | Tagged , , , | Comments Off

Welcome to 5MFI

 

21 January 2103

Five Minutes for IsraelJacqueline Mulhern Hartholz

Five Minutes for Israel is delighted to welcome Jacqueline as a regular contributor. Her special interests are Ireland for which we are opening a new category (name to be announced) and Twitter and of course any other Israel advocate subject she wants to contribute.

Posted in 5MFI Blog | Tagged , | Comments Off

Compass points

15 January 2013

Locating the inner voter

I have been called a fascist, a bigot and a racist (and that’s only by family). Also extremely rude. OK I’ll own up to that one. But look at the chart based on my opinions. I am represented by the red dot. I’m just about as centrist as possible to be! Where do YOU fit on the Israeli Political Compass?

Israel political compass

Click this text link to do the test yourself
Glick graphic for a larger view?

Domestic or imported (politics), Sir?

When Five Minutes for Israelwas created it was decided to avoid Israeli and domestic politics elsewhere. That was an acknowledgment that Israel advocates come from all over the political spectrum. It was not our intention to alienate any potential supporter. That surprises many outsiders convinced that supporting Israel transforms one into a right-winger.

As Nicky Larkin noted in a piece coincidentally titled My political compass:

So therefore in “coming out” as a Zionist, I have automatically been labeled as a raving right-wing nut job. This confuses me greatly. Do the people holding those political compasses not realize that Israel’s very foundation was as a socialist state? Interestingly, the only place I’ve found it generally acceptable to have the words “leftwing” and “Zionist” in the same sentence is in Israel itself. Everywhere else, being a Zionist is automatically equivalent to being a right-wing lunatic and a Fox News fan. 

One doesn’t have to visit the Emerald Isle to experience this. I have met many olim who have told me that back in America/Britain/Australia they were active supporters of the Democrats/Labour Party/Australian Labor Party. Then without moving their opinions as much as one centimetre rightward they land at Ben Gurion to discover they are now not only right-wingers but extreme right wingers! This is one reason I try to avoid labeling any position on the Israel-Palestine-Arab-Muslim conflict as left, right or even the most abused term of all – centrist. (Please read Israel vs. everybody, the Pyramid model: A multidimensional model for locating the elephants in the room† for more about graphically positioning this conflict on an international rather than domestic scale). This is also my reason for supporting the Political Compass’s attempt to provide descriptive analysis that steps beyond the totally misleading left/right labels. If the Israeli model corresponds to the general political compassset-up the further you are to the top of the chart the more authoritarian you are. Conversely the closer to the bottom the more libertarian. Left and Right remain the same.

Mao Zedung - Dalai Lama composite

Two left-wing faces of the same coin?
I don’t think so.

Left right out of the picture

I like to explain the concept like this. By general consensus Mao Zedong (Mao Tse-tung) and the 14th Dalai Lama are both left-wingers. Does that tell us anything we can use to predict behaviour? I don’t think so. But when you realise that Mao is very high (off the chart?) on the Authoritarian scale while the Lama is strongly on the Libertarian scale that a truer picture emerges. Just think about that when someone tells you that Prime Minister Netanyahu is an extreme right-winger but doesn’t think Mahmud Abbas has any wings, all.Or when some self described left-winger fails, heaven forbid, to describe Hamas leader Ismail Haniyeh as a Fascist.

Action items:

Do the test yourself. The 2013 Election Compass, The Israel Democracy Institute

Further reading:


† Originally titled Always look for the elephant. For some strange WordPress reason I can’t save that title and it always comes out as Auto Draft. Search engines do locate it under the original title. Help?
Posted in 5MFI Blog | Tagged , , | Comments Off